The Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) investment framework has emerged as a crucial mechanism for developing Vietnam’s seaport infrastructure, offering significant opportunities for both domestic and international investors while supporting the nation’s maritime development goals.
1. Introduction
Vietnam’s strategic location along major shipping routes has positioned its seaport sector as a vital component of regional maritime trade. The Vietnamese government has been heavily investing in modernizing port infrastructure through BOT (Build-Operate-Transfer) investment projects, facilitating private sector participation in the development and operation of seaports. This policy not only enhances the competitiveness of ports but also promotes technology transfer, international standards, and advanced management practices, contributing to improved maritime transport services. Furthermore, increased BOT investment generates positive spillover effects by improving the transportation infrastructure linked to ports, thereby supporting economic growth and the development of key economic regions.
Current Market Significance
In the context of deep global economic integration, Vietnam’s seaport sector has experienced significant growth, with increasing cargo volumes and vessel traffic. This development reflects not only the economic potential of the sector but also the critical role of seaports in facilitating international trade. BOT investment plays a key role in bridging the financial gap for infrastructure and integrating international operational standards into seaports. BOT projects optimize operational efficiency and enable the adoption of modern technologies, from smart management to maritime safety, improving service quality while minimizing operational risks.
Key Stakeholders
The success of BOT investment projects in seaports depends on the coordinated efforts of multiple stakeholders. Government agencies play a guiding role in policy formulation and regulatory oversight, ensuring that projects are implemented on schedule and meet quality standards. Meanwhile, private investors are expected to bring in strong capital resources, modern management expertise, and operational experience, driving innovation and sustainable development. Port operators and maritime service providers also play a crucial role in implementing international standards, ensuring safety and efficiency in cargo handling and transport operations. Continuous interaction and a deep understanding of each party’s role minimise risks and create a transparent business environment, fostering synchronized development across Vietnam’s seaport infrastructure. Establishing strong collaborative relationships among stakeholders will be a decisive factor in successfully implementing BOT projects, contributing to the comprehensive development of the seaport sector in the era of global economic integration.
2. Legal Framework
2.1 Vietnamese BOT Regulations
The legal foundation for BOT investments in seaports is established through comprehensive regulations that define investor rights, obligations, and operational parameters. These include the Public-Private Partnership Law and specific decrees governing maritime infrastructure development.
In the context of public-private partnership (PPP) project development, BOT contracts (Clause a, Article 16, Article 3 and Clause 1, Article 45 of the 2020 Law on Public-Private Partnership Investment) are legally binding agreements through which the state grants investors the right to implement projects under current laws. Under this model, investors are responsible for financing, constructing, operating, and managing the project for a defined period to recover investment costs and generate profits. Upon completing the business term, project assets are fully transferred back to the state. The key characteristics of BOT contracts include mobilizing private capital, risk-sharing between the public and private sectors, and facilitating the adoption of advanced technologies and efficient management, thereby improving service quality and the economic efficiency of public infrastructure projects.
2.2 Maritime Law Considerations
Relevant legal documents:
- Vietnam Maritime Code (2015 and subsequent amendments)
- Decree No. 58/2017/ND-CP detailing certain provisions of the Vietnam Maritime Code on maritime operations management
For maritime and port-related projects, BOT contracts serve not only as a tool for mobilizing private capital but also incorporate essential maritime legal elements. Specifically, these contracts must integrate regulations on maritime safety, vessel traffic management, and cargo handling to ensure port operations comply with international standards and specialized legal provisions. Key maritime legal considerations, such as cargo loading and unloading regulations, vessel traffic control, and maritime safety and environmental protection measures, are essential to ensuring the safety and commercial viability of the project.
2.3 Investment Protection Mechanisms
Vietnam has implemented robust investment protection measures, including:
- Protection against nationalization: Vietnam commits not to nationalize foreign investors’ assets except as provided by law, with fair and reasonable compensation. Specifically, Article 10 of the Investment Law guarantees investor property rights, ensuring that assets are not nationalized or confiscated through administrative measures. In cases where the state requisitions assets for national defense, security, public interest, emergency, or disaster prevention, investors are entitled to legal compensation.
- Capital transfer rights: Foreign investors have the right to transfer their investment capital and related assets. Article 46 of the Investment Law outlines conditions for investors to transfer part or all of their investment projects to other investors.
- Dispute resolution through international arbitration: Given the long-term nature and risks associated with BOT projects due to economic and policy fluctuations, Article 97 of the 2020 Law on Public-Private Partnership Investment provides clear dispute resolution provisions. In case of conflicts, disputes are resolved through negotiation, mediation, arbitration (with international arbitration being a common choice), or court proceedings, ensuring a prompt, fair, and efficient resolution process.
3. BOT Investment Process
3.1 Application Procedures
The BOT application process involves several stages, from initial project proposal to final approval. Investors must prepare comprehensive documentation demonstrating technical capability, financial strength, and project viability.
Project implementation procedures: (Chapters III-V of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP guiding the PPP Investment Law)
- Preparation, appraisal of the pre-feasibility study report, and investment policy approval
- Preparation, appraisal of the feasibility study report, and project approval
- Selection of investors and signing of the project contract
Project implementation - Confirmation of project completion and infrastructure system
- Transfer of project assets
3.2 Required Documentation
1. Pre-feasibility study report and appraisal (Clause 3, Article 14; Clause 2, Article 15 of the PPP Investment Law; Article 17 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP)
- Pre-feasibility study report (Annex II, Form No. 01 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP)
- Appraisal report of the pre-feasibility study (Annex II, Form No. 02 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP)
- 10 sets of documents (additional copies may be required if necessary)
2. Feasibility study report and appraisal (Clause 2, Article 19; Clause 2, Article 20 of the PPP Investment Law; Article 24 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP)
- Feasibility study report (Annex III, Form No. 01 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP)
- Appraisal report of the feasibility study (Annex III, Form No. 02 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP)
10 sets of documents (additional copies may be required if necessary)
3. Investment policy approval application (Article 16 of the PPP Investment Law; Article 21 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP)
- Application form and draft investment policy approval decision
- Pre-feasibility study report and its appraisal report
- 10 sets of documents (additional copies may be required if necessary)
4. Project approval application (Article 22 of the PPP Investment Law; Article 27 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP)
- Application form and draft project approval decision
- Feasibility study report and its appraisal report
Investment policy approval decision - 10 sets of documents (additional copies may be required if necessary)
3.3 Timeline and Key Milestones
A typical BOT project timeline spans multiple years, from initial approval through construction and operational phases. Understanding key milestones helps investors plan resources and manage expectations effectively.
Key timelines:
- Investment policy appraisal (Article 18 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP): 30-45 days
- Feasibility study appraisal (Article 26 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP): 60-90 days
- Investor selection (Article 31 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP): 6-7 months
- Project completion confirmation (Article 76 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP): 30 days from the date of receiving complete documents.
- Project and infrastructure system transfer (Article 78 of Decree 35/2021/ND-CP): Up to 1 year before contract termination.
4. Investment Guidelines
4.1 Eligibility Criteria
Investors must meet specific eligibility requirements, including financial capacity, technical expertise, and operational experience in port development and management. The selection of investors for major port projects often requires additional clarifications to ensure project feasibility and effectiveness.
Capital Requirements
BOT projects typically require substantial capital investment, with specific requirements varying based on project scale and scope. Investors must demonstrate access to adequate funding sources and financial stability. According to the Vietnam Law Newspaper, the development plan for Vietnam’s port system until 2030 estimates a total investment capital demand of approximately VND 351,500 billion.
Risk Allocation
Understanding and managing risk allocation between public and private partners is crucial. Key risks include:
- Construction risk: Delays, cost overruns.
- Operational risk: Underperformance.
- Market risk: Fluctuations in maritime transport demand.
- Regulatory risk: Changes in management regulations.
A fair risk-sharing mechanism between the state and investors is essential for project success. Many BOT projects have faced difficulties due to lower-than-expected toll revenues, creating financial pressure on investors.
5. Investment Opportunities
5.1 Priority Port Projects
The government has identified key port development projects under the BOT (Build – Operate – Transfer) model, focusing on strategic locations and high-growth potential areas. For instance, according to the Government Electronic Newspaper, the Phu Quoc International Passenger Port project was implemented under the BOT model with state budget support to boost tourism and the local economy.
5.2 Growth Sectors
Opportunities exist in various port-related sectors, including container terminals, bulk cargo facilities, and specialized ports serving industrial zones.
There are numerous opportunities in port-related sectors, including:
- Container ports: Addressing the increasing demand for cargo transportation. According to the Business Forum Magazine, the Vietnam Inland Waterways Administration has proposed studying various preferential policies to attract investment in port system development and inland waterway infrastructure.
- Bulk cargo terminals: Facilitating the import and export of raw materials and non-containerized goods.
- Dedicated industrial ports: Supporting logistics for industrial zones and enhancing supply chain efficiency.
5.3 Government Incentives
Investors can benefit from various incentives, including:
- Tax exemptions and reductions: Preferential tax rates, full tax exemptions for the initial years, followed by partial reductions in subsequent years.
- Land lease reductions: Full exemption from land and water surface rental fees for the entire lease period.
- Import duty exemptions for equipment: Exemptions on imported handling equipment for containers, bulk cargo, and specialized goods that are not domestically produced to enhance port cargo handling capacity.
According to Vneconomy, Soc Trang province is undertaking necessary procedures to attract investment in the Tran De International Deep-Sea Port project under a socialization model. Investors will enjoy various incentives such as a 10% preferential tax rate for 15 years, a 4-year tax exemption, a 50% reduction in payable taxes for the next 9 years, and full exemption from land and water surface rental fees for the entire lease period.
Additionally, Saigon Giai Phong Online reports various mechanisms and policies to attract investment in Tran De Port development, including: a 5% corporate income tax rate for 37 years, a 50% tax reduction for the next 13 years, a 22-year exemption from land and water surface rental fees, and a 75% reduction for the remaining period. The proposed land lease term is 70 years, with exemptions on import duties for machinery, equipment, and components not produced domestically. The project will also facilitate the conversion of protective forest land through financial contributions to the state budget, adopt a bidding process for investor selection, and allow the use of marine sand materials for port infrastructure development.
6. Case Studies and Best Practices
6.1 Successful BOT Port Projects
Several BOT port projects in Vietnam have achieved high profitability and operational efficiency, providing valuable lessons on effective implementation strategies.
According to VnExpress, the Tan Cang – Hai Phong International Container Terminal (TC-HICT) BOT project in Lach Huyen, Hai Phong, has demonstrated profitability and efficiency in port infrastructure investment. Inaugurated in 2018, TC-HICT is the first and largest deep-water container port in Northern Vietnam, capable of accommodating vessels of up to 14,000 TEU. This enables direct import-export shipments to Europe and America without transshipment, significantly reducing logistics time and costs.
The success of TC-HICT has paved the way for the expansion of new berths in Lach Huyen. Specifically, Berths 3 and 4, invested by Hai Phong Port Joint Stock Company, and Berths 5 and 6, developed by Hateco Group, are expected to commence operations in 2025. These projects promise to enhance the region’s cargo throughput capacity while boosting the competitiveness of Vietnam’s port system on the global stage.
6.2 Lessons Learned
- Thorough preparation: Comprehensive market assessment, transport demand evaluation, and infrastructure connectivity analysis are fundamental to successful project planning and execution.
- Multilateral collaboration: Partnerships with both domestic and international stakeholders, as seen in the TC-HICT joint venture model, play a crucial role in capital mobilization, technology transfer, and efficient management.
- Flexible risk management: Identifying and equitably distributing risks among stakeholders ensures project progress and quality while optimizing economic benefits.
- Infrastructure connectivity enhancement: Coordinated investment in transportation systems linking ports with industrial zones, logistics centers, and road, rail, and inland waterway networks facilitates cargo flow and reduces transportation costs.
Experience from existing projects highlights the importance of thorough preparation, stakeholder engagement, and adaptive management in ensuring project success.
6.3 Best Practices
- Comprehensive due diligence: Conducting thorough economic, technical, and environmental feasibility assessments before project implementation.
- Strong local partnerships: Engaging with regulatory authorities and local communities to address legal and social concerns while fostering project support.
- Effective risk management strategies: Identifying and equitably allocating risks among stakeholders while establishing mitigation and contingency measures.
- Clear communication channels with authorities: Maintaining frequent and transparent interactions with government agencies to ensure compliance and timely resolution of emerging issues.
- Regular stakeholder engagement: Building strong relationships with investors, contractors, suppliers, and local communities to ensure coordinated efforts and mutual support throughout project execution.
7. Conclusion
BOT investment in Vietnamese seaports presents significant opportunities for investors willing to navigate the regulatory landscape and commit to long-term development. Success requires careful planning, thorough understanding of legal requirements, and effective risk management strategies.
For more information about BOT investment opportunities in Vietnamese seaports, contact the Ministry of Transport’s Department of Public-Private Partnership Investment or visit their official website for detailed guidelines and current projects.
For detailed legal advice, don’t hesitate to contact Harley Miller Law Firm
- Hotline: + 84 9372 15585
- Email: info@luatminhnguyen.com
- Website: luatminhnguyen.com or hmlf.vn
